American Idol (Show Discussion)

by Guest 1/24/2010, 3:35 am

Discuss the show here...

I think this show is ok now but not as good as it once was.

by **that70sguy92** 1/24/2010, 2:07 pm

This show has its ups and downs. Unfortunately, with all the drama behind the judge's table recently, it's mostly been downs.

by **tvguy347** 1/29/2010, 12:34 am

Don't care for it. Don't like Simon, Kara, and Paula. Randys okay.

by **Wumbology** 1/29/2010, 3:05 pm

PANTS ON THE GROUND
PANTS ON THE GROUND
LOOKIN' LIKE A FOOL WIT YOUR PANTS ON THE GROUND

Guys like him are the prime reason I watch this show.

by **terminoob** 1/29/2010, 3:32 pm

tvguy347 wrote:Don't care for it. Don't like Simon, Kara, and Paula. Randys okay.

How the flip do you not like Simon? He made the show the huge hit that it is.

by **The Cartoon** 2/7/2010, 5:15 pm

The season is pretty good so far. I never really liked Paula anyway. I think that Ellen will make it way more entertaining.

by **tvguy347** 2/7/2010, 5:39 pm

because he's a jerk and puts people down. :p

by **webizoid345** 2/21/2010, 12:00 pm

I love this show, watched it ever since the 4th season, but this season, why did they let that skinny black girl in instead of Tori Kelly? That was a GIANT mistake. But ellen makes this show AWESOME! But she isn't always a joking person, she can bring some critisism to the table. I don't know why so many people don't like her! :O

by **tvguy347** 10/3/2010, 12:52 pm

I wonder who will replace Ellen and Simon.

by **that70sguy92** 10/3/2010, 4:42 pm

tvguy347 wrote:I wonder who will replace Ellen and Simon.

It's been known for a long time.

New judges table:
Randy Jackson
Steven Tyler
Jennifer Lopez

I don't know if I'll watch.

by **tvguy347** 10/3/2010, 5:12 pm

that70sguy92 wrote:
tvguy347 wrote:I wonder who will replace Ellen and Simon.
It's been known for a long time.

New judges table:
Randy Jackson
Steven Tyler
Jennifer Lopez

I don't know if I'll watch.

Meh. It's not the same as it was anymore. They might as well boot off Randy. =/

Wait, where's Kara?

by **Wumbology** 10/3/2010, 5:54 pm

tvguy347 wrote:
that70sguy92 wrote:
tvguy347 wrote:I wonder who will replace Ellen and Simon.
It's been known for a long time.

New judges table:
Randy Jackson
Steven Tyler
Jennifer Lopez

I don't know if I'll watch.

Meh. It's not the same as it was anymore. They might as well boot off Randy. =/

Wait, where's Kara?

She got fired, long overdue.

Anyway, I'm probably going to watch the first ep to see what it's like.

by **tvguy347** 10/3/2010, 6:00 pm

Wumbology wrote:
tvguy347 wrote:
that70sguy92 wrote:
tvguy347 wrote:I wonder who will replace Ellen and Simon.
It's been known for a long time.

New judges table:
Randy Jackson
Steven Tyler
Jennifer Lopez

I don't know if I'll watch.

Meh. It's not the same as it was anymore. They might as well boot off Randy. =/

Wait, where's Kara?
She got fired, long overdue.

Anyway, I'm probably going to watch the first ep to see what it's like.

Same here. But I hate how there is one original judge left. It's not American Idol without the judges. Sad

by **Wumbology** 10/3/2010, 7:43 pm

tvguy347 wrote:
Wumbology wrote:
tvguy347 wrote:
that70sguy92 wrote:
tvguy347 wrote:I wonder who will replace Ellen and Simon.
It's been known for a long time.

New judges table:
Randy Jackson
Steven Tyler
Jennifer Lopez

I don't know if I'll watch.

Meh. It's not the same as it was anymore. They might as well boot off Randy. =/

Wait, where's Kara?
She got fired, long overdue.

Anyway, I'm probably going to watch the first ep to see what it's like.

Same here. But I hate how there is one original judge left. It's not American Idol without the judges.

Simon Cowell pretty much made the show (literally and figuratively Silly Face!

), so I won't be surprised if barely anybody watches.

by **The Cartoon** 10/4/2010, 9:44 am

Steven Tyler will be a good judge. I don't think J-Lo will be. I've always liked Randy. I mean, I'll watch the season but I'd be pretty surprised if this wasn't the last one.

by **storytime7** 12/14/2010, 9:54 pm

Use to like it, but I lost interest in it during that season with "Sanjaya". Haven't watched it at all since.

by **Clappy** 12/14/2010, 9:57 pm

Has gone incredibly downhill.

I mean actually finding talent from the newer seasons is like trying to find diversity in an Abercrombie and Fitch catalog (Yes, FG reference deal with it since it applys here too)

by **that70sguy92** 12/14/2010, 9:59 pm

storytime7 wrote:Use to like it, but I lost interest in it during that season with "Sanjaya". Haven't watched it at all since.

Sanjaya was awesome! Whoa!

by **tvguy347** 1/29/2011, 12:02 pm

So what do you guys think of the new season?

I was actually pleasantly surprised. There's a vast range of amazing voices, and I find Steven Tyler funny. J-Lo is pretty cool, but I'm actually not very fond of Randy Jackson this year. =/

by Guest 1/29/2011, 3:04 pm

I haven't watched it since the season where Jasmine Trias was in it.

by **Wumbology** 1/29/2011, 3:23 pm

Randy seems like he's trying to replace Simon, and he's not doing a very good job, if that's the case.

That said, I do like Steven Tyler. Kind of indifferent towards Lopez, but damn, she is stunning.

by **spongebobiscool** 1/29/2011, 3:34 pm

The show isn't that good without simon ,but im watching it anyways its still funny. I heard they push the age limit lower to 15.

by **Wumbology** 1/29/2011, 3:47 pm

spongbobiscool wrote:I heard they push the age limit lower to 15.

I hope that we get to see them send at least one 15-year-old out without a golden ticket.

by **spongebobiscool** 1/29/2011, 4:07 pm

That never happened before , but lets see.

by **Wumbology** 1/29/2011, 8:06 pm

That one girl whining "OMIGAWD I WANT THIS SO BAD!!!111" was pathetic, and the one thing I have against lowering the age limit. You don't have to be good, you just have to blubber like a baby and you're through to Hollywood.

by **that70sguy92** 2/5/2011, 7:40 pm

Did you guys notice the recent Steven Tyler apology?

It was absolute BULLSHIT! The auditions are taped months in advance, and everyone knows it. Publicity stunt.

by **Clappy** 2/5/2011, 7:42 pm

Hold Me Tight wrote:Did you guys notice the recent Steven Tyler apology?

It was absolute BULLSHIT! The auditions are taped months in advance, and everyone knows it. Publicity stunt.

Wait what did Steven Tyler apologize about? That's how much American Idol I have not been watching this season Silly Face!

by **that70sguy92** 2/5/2011, 7:43 pm

Hey Jude wrote:
Hold Me Tight wrote:Did you guys notice the recent Steven Tyler apology?

It was absolute BULLSHIT! The auditions are taped months in advance, and everyone knows it. Publicity stunt.

Wait what did Steven Tyler apologize about? That's how much American Idol I have not been watching this season

by **tvguy347** 2/5/2011, 8:02 pm

Hold Me Tight wrote:Did you guys notice the recent Steven Tyler apology?

It was absolute BULLSHIT! The auditions are taped months in advance, and everyone knows it. Publicity stunt.

I don't see how the hell his behavior was 'outrageous' at all. >.> But you're right, 70s. Just a big ass publicity stunt. Most likely to boost ratings, as it's pretty obvious this show is going downhill.

by **Clappy** 2/5/2011, 8:21 pm

Hold Me Tight wrote:
Hey Jude wrote:
Hold Me Tight wrote:Did you guys notice the recent Steven Tyler apology?

It was absolute BULLSHIT! The auditions are taped months in advance, and everyone knows it. Publicity stunt.

Wait what did Steven Tyler apologize about? That's how much American Idol I have not been watching this season

Wow, really? Good lord, how dare they be apologetic since his last name rhymes with fuck >.>.

by **The Cartoon** 2/12/2011, 10:25 am

Oh yeah, the Steven Tyler thing was planned. There was nothing stopping them from not showing the footage, and pretending like it never happened. So why would they draw attention to it?

Anyway, I actually prefer the show with this panel of judges. Simon was good and all, but I think that Steven Tyler and Jennifer Lopez are better judges than Simon & Paula, and way more compassionate. And there are a ton of really talented singers this year, especially young ones. Just one more week until the Top 20. SOO Happy

by **spongebobiscool** 3/4/2011, 11:14 pm

The Cartoon wrote:Oh yeah, the Steven Tyler thing was planned. There was nothing stopping them from not showing the footage, and pretending like it never happened. and Jennifer Lopez are better judges than Simon & Paula, and way more compassionate.

I disagree the old judges were way better than the new judges cuz there was more simon jokes that made us laugh.

by **Wumbology** 3/5/2011, 8:52 am

The only thing I'm not too keen about with the judges is that somebody apparently needed to step up and be the next Simon Cowell. Enter Randy Jackson.

Sorry man, but you're no Simon Cowell, nor will you ever be. Stop it. Thank you.

While I do miss Simon Cowell, I'm pretty pleased with the new judges. Steven Tyler's cool, and as I said before, J-Lo is stunning.

by **Clappy** 3/5/2011, 11:13 am

I really like the new judges, but I hate how Randy is trying too hard to be the next Simon Cowell. Otherwise, the three have really good chemistry together.

by **spongebobiscool** 3/7/2011, 5:26 pm

what do u guys think of the top 24 now?

by **Wumbology** 3/7/2011, 7:15 pm

spongbobiscool wrote:what do u guys think of the top 24 now?

I think they're short a couple people.

by **spongebobiscool** 3/7/2011, 10:21 pm

so know one is at least 6 feet from the top 24 lol

by **Wumbology** 3/8/2011, 8:10 am

spongbobiscool wrote:so know one is at least 6 feet from the top 24 lol

Yeah, but it's a Top 13 now, not a Top 24. Silly Face!

by **that70sguy92** 3/8/2011, 11:02 am

spongbobiscool wrote:so know one is at least 6 feet from the top 24 lol

Archive'd.

by **Clappy** 3/8/2011, 11:53 am

that70sguy92 wrote:
spongbobiscool wrote:so know one is at least 6 feet from the top 24 lol
Archive'd.

Archive'd because of spongbobiscool's incredibly lulzy, but poor grammar? Then every single post he makes needs to be archived in that case Silly Face!

by **spongebobiscool** 3/8/2011, 5:05 pm

um.........what archive?

by **Wumbology** 3/8/2011, 5:34 pm

Clappy wrote:
that70sguy92 wrote:
spongbobiscool wrote:so know one is at least 6 feet from the top 24 lol
Archive'd.
Archive'd because of spongbobiscool's incredibly lulzy, but poor grammar? Then every single post he makes needs to be archived in that case

I think it was more because he misunderstood what I meant by "short".

by **that70sguy92** 3/8/2011, 5:56 pm

Clappy wrote:
that70sguy92 wrote:
spongbobiscool wrote:so know one is at least 6 feet from the top 24 lol
Archive'd.
Archive'd because of spongbobiscool's incredibly lulzy, but poor grammar? Then every single post he makes needs to be archived in that case

Archive'd becase I have literally no idea what he's talking about.

by **Wumbology** 3/8/2011, 6:54 pm

ARCHIVE-WORTHY POST:

My banana monkey power is flaming blue and purquoise.

by **Clappy** 3/8/2011, 7:55 pm

Wumbology wrote:ARCHIVE-WORTHY POST:

My banana monkey power is flaming blue and purquoise.

Lolololololol ARCHIVED!!!

Spoiler:

by **Wumbology** 3/8/2011, 8:13 pm

Clappy wrote:
Wumbology wrote:ARCHIVE-WORTHY POST:

My banana monkey power is flaming blue and purquoise.
Lolololololol ARCHIVED!!!

Spoiler:

Fu. >=O

by **Clappy** 3/8/2011, 8:17 pm

Wumbology wrote:
Clappy wrote:
Wumbology wrote:ARCHIVE-WORTHY POST:

My banana monkey power is flaming blue and purquoise.
Lolololololol ARCHIVED!!!

Spoiler:
Fu. >=O

American Idol (Show Discussion) Tumblr_lhjscbWl4U1qdpvc3

by **spongebobiscool** 3/8/2011, 9:23 pm

then what did u mean by short cuz i thought u meant short ppl as in short height?

by **that70sguy92** 3/10/2011, 3:24 pm

spongbobiscool wrote:then what did u mean by short cuz i thought u meant short ppl as in short height?

It means that... okay, it's just easier to call you stupid.

by **Wumbology** 3/10/2011, 4:51 pm

spongbobiscool wrote:then what did u mean by short cuz i thought u meant short ppl as in short height?

I meant as in a shortage, a lack of contestants.

by Sponsored content